SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP, INC (SIGI) Scorecard
- 2026-Q2: Total return Win; Revenue growth Lose; EPS growth Lose.
- 2026-Q1: Total return Lose; Revenue growth Lose; EPS growth Win.
- 2025-Q4: Total return Win; Revenue growth Win; EPS growth Win.
- 2025-Q3: Total return Lose; Revenue growth Win; EPS growth Win.
69/120
All 120 Win/Lose results shown below
Every strict quarterly win earns 1 point. A loss, tie, or unavailable scoring value earns 0.
Trailing 1 year (4 quarters): 7 wins, 5 lossesLast fetched: 4 Sept 2026
Complete point ledger
Each cell identifies the missing side explicitly.
| Quarter | Total return | Revenue growth | EPS growth |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-Q21/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 29.32% / 15.20% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 7.01% / 15.00% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 31.91% / 50.40% |
| 2026-Q11/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -9.45% / -4.33% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 8.61% / 11.30% |
WinSIGI / S&P 99.18% / 27.70% |
| 2025-Q43/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 3.77% / 2.65% |
WinSIGI / S&P 9.78% / 9.00% |
WinSIGI / S&P 132.61% / 13.40% |
| 2025-Q32/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -5.98% / 8.12% |
WinSIGI / S&P 10.87% / 4.61% |
WinSIGI / S&P 74.93% / 13.45% |
| 2025-Q22/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -4.92% / 10.94% |
WinSIGI / S&P 12.30% / 4.83% |
WinSIGI / S&P 66.94% / 10.63% |
| 2025-Q12/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P -1.67% / -4.27% |
WinSIGI / S&P 13.30% / 4.98% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -35.16% / 10.57% |
| 2024-Q41/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 0.62% / 2.41% |
WinSIGI / S&P 14.88% / 5.25% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -44.77% / 6.15% |
| 2024-Q31/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -0.16% / 5.89% |
WinSIGI / S&P 15.77% / 5.89% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -28.65% / 6.11% |
| 2024-Q21/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -13.74% / 4.28% |
WinSIGI / S&P 17.11% / 5.38% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -17.57% / 5.12% |
| 2024-Q12/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 10.12% / 10.56% |
WinSIGI / S&P 18.47% / 5.71% |
WinSIGI / S&P 37.05% / 5.59% |
| 2023-Q42/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -3.25% / 11.69% |
WinSIGI / S&P 18.94% / 6.81% |
WinSIGI / S&P 64.69% / 7.78% |
| 2023-Q33/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.85% / -3.27% |
WinSIGI / S&P 17.21% / 7.52% |
WinSIGI / S&P 39.04% / -5.03% |
| 2023-Q22/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 0.95% / 8.74% |
WinSIGI / S&P 12.83% / 9.50% |
WinSIGI / S&P 4.23% / -8.57% |
| 2023-Q11/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.90% / 7.50% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 8.49% / 10.77% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -26.64% / -15.69% |
| 2022-Q41/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 9.22% / 7.56% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 5.29% / 11.88% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -45.62% / -17.99% |
| 2022-Q30/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -6.05% / -4.88% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 5.07% / 13.47% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -46.87% / -1.41% |
| 2022-Q21/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P -2.35% / -16.10% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 7.03% / 13.71% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -39.32% / 11.04% |
| 2022-Q11/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 9.46% / -4.60% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 11.76% / 15.97% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 0.36% / 42.23% |
| 2021-Q41/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 8.87% / 11.03% |
WinSIGI / S&P 15.63% / 15.00% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 59.17% / 96.40% |
| 2021-Q32/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -6.65% / 0.58% |
WinSIGI / S&P 15.96% / 10.77% |
WinSIGI / S&P 110.15% / 69.42% |
| 2021-Q23/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 12.25% / 8.55% |
WinSIGI / S&P 15.53% / 6.58% |
WinSIGI / S&P 125.00% / 51.81% |
| 2021-Q13/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 8.71% / 6.17% |
WinSIGI / S&P 8.85% / -1.06% |
WinSIGI / S&P 49.20% / 7.39% |
| 2020-Q43/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 30.62% / 12.15% |
WinSIGI / S&P 2.66% / -3.72% |
WinSIGI / S&P -9.71% / -33.42% |
| 2020-Q32/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -1.97% / 8.93% |
WinSIGI / S&P 3.34% / -2.04% |
WinSIGI / S&P -14.76% / -27.10% |
| 2020-Q22/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 6.67% / 20.54% |
WinSIGI / S&P 2.65% / -0.46% |
WinSIGI / S&P -20.61% / -27.11% |
| 2020-Q12/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -23.51% / -19.60% |
WinSIGI / S&P 5.79% / 3.47% |
WinSIGI / S&P 1.35% / -14.75% |
| 2019-Q42/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -13.00% / 9.07% |
WinSIGI / S&P 10.07% / 5.36% |
WinSIGI / S&P 50.50% / 2.99% |
| 2019-Q32/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 0.65% / 1.70% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.13% / 5.02% |
WinSIGI / S&P 43.43% / 0.21% |
| 2019-Q23/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 18.68% / 4.30% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.14% / 6.64% |
WinSIGI / S&P 51.15% / 8.65% |
| 2019-Q11/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P 4.16% / 13.65% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 6.50% / 8.12% |
WinSIGI / S&P 60.61% / 14.29% |
| 2018-Q41/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P -3.73% / -13.52% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 4.70% / 9.05% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 5.99% / 18.23% |
| 2018-Q31/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 15.79% / 7.71% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 6.54% / 10.21% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -8.97% / 19.06% |
| 2018-Q20/3 |
LoseSIGI / S&P -9.10% / 3.43% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 6.50% / 9.03% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -9.72% / 14.46% |
| 2018-Q11/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 3.73% / -0.76% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 6.98% / 7.68% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -20.89% / 12.46% |
| 2017-Q42/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 9.34% / 6.64% |
WinSIGI / S&P 8.13% / 7.03% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 5.19% / 13.82% |
| 2017-Q32/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.93% / 4.48% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.62% / 5.68% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 7.50% / 17.57% |
| 2017-Q22/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 6.49% / 3.09% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.83% / 4.83% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -2.37% / 17.74% |
| 2017-Q12/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 9.93% / 6.07% |
WinSIGI / S&P 8.05% / 3.67% |
LoseSIGI / S&P 4.66% / 13.32% |
| 2016-Q42/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 8.47% / 3.82% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.15% / 2.09% |
LoseSIGI / S&P -5.26% / 7.05% |
| 2016-Q33/3 |
WinSIGI / S&P 4.72% / 3.85% |
WinSIGI / S&P 7.54% / 0.20% |
WinSIGI / S&P -0.00% / -3.15% |
Dividend-reinvested, split-adjusted total return
1Y · 2025-08-29 to 2026-08-27
| Metric | SIGI total return | S&P 500 Total Return Index |
|---|---|---|
| Total return | 20.36% | 20.78% |
| Annualized return | 20.36% | 20.78% |
5Y · 2021-09-01 to 2026-08-27
| Metric | SIGI total return | S&P 500 Total Return Index |
|---|---|---|
| Total return | 18.82% | 83.14% |
| Annualized return | 3.51% | 12.86% |
10Y · 2016-09-01 to 2026-08-27
| Metric | SIGI total return | S&P 500 Total Return Index |
|---|---|---|
| Total return | 166.14% | 319.30% |
| Annualized return | 10.28% | 15.41% |
Calculation rules
- window
- Latest 40 completed benchmark quarters; unavailable issuer evidence remains visible and scores 0.
- return Basis
- Issuer adjusted close reinvests distributions and normalizes splits; the S&P 500 Total Return Index is the direct benchmark.
- point Rule
- Strict same-quarter win = 1. Loss, tie or unavailable evidence = 0. No partial or subjective points.
- frequency
- Quarter endpoints only.
- fundamentals
- Trailing-four-quarter issuer revenue and EPS growth use the issuer's normalized government-filed facts.
- non Scoring
Snapshot captured 2026-09-04.
Similar stocks
| Stock Name | Country | Market Cap | PE Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| RLI CORP (RLI) | United States | $5.155B | 12.36 |
| WHITE MOUNTAINS INSURANCE GROUP LTD (WTM) | United States | $4.846B | 4.17 |
| MERCURY GENERAL CORP (MCY) | United States | $5.443B | 6.30 |
| Lemonade, Inc. (LMND) | United States | $3.505B | -36.34 |
| Palomar Holdings, Inc. (PLMR) | United States | $3.307B | 16.30 |
| AXIS CAPITAL HOLDINGS LTD (AXS) | $6.985B | 7.01 | |
| SiriusPoint Ltd (SPNT) | $2.998B | 5.51 | |
| Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. (SLDE) | United States | $2.750B | 4.03 |
| HANOVER INSURANCE GROUP, INC. (THG) | United States | $7.592B | 9.91 |
| Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. (KNSL) | United States | $7.755B | 13.21 |