NYSE:AFG | Roast Me | AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC

52/120 All 120 Win/Lose results shown below

Every strict quarterly win earns 1 point. A loss, tie, or unavailable scoring value earns 0. Gray context columns never affect the score. CEO quarterly pay is the explicitly marked annual ÷ 4 estimate.

Trailing 1 year (4 quarters): 1 wins, 11 lossesLast fetched: 4 Sept 2026

Complete point ledger

Each cell identifies the missing side explicitly. Unavailable evidence scores 0 only in Win/Lose columns; gray columns award no points.

QuarterTotal returnRevenue growthEPS growthNet marginNon-scoringTrailing P/ENon-scoringPrice/bookNon-scoringCEO quarterly payNon-scoringImplied DilutionNon-scoringImplied BuybackNon-scoring
2026-Q20/3 LoseAFG / S&P
10.32% / 15.20%
LoseAFG / S&P
-0.24% / 15.00%
LoseAFG / S&P
25.71% / 50.40%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.51% / 15.70%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.18 / 28.47
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.41 / S&P unavailable
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / S&P unavailable
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.36b
2026-Q10/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-4.83% / -4.33%
LoseAFG / S&P
-1.23% / 11.30%
LoseAFG / S&P
10.50% / 27.70%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.76% / 14.80%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.07 / 25.43
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.27 / S&P unavailable
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / S&P unavailable
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.27b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
2025-Q40/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-4.27% / 2.65%
LoseAFG / S&P
-1.80% / 9.00%
LoseAFG / S&P
-4.73% / 13.40%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.30% / 13.20%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.54 / 28.48
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.37 / 5.39
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.42m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.20b
2025-Q31/3 WinAFG / S&P
16.18% / 8.12%
LoseAFG / S&P
0.02% / 4.61%
LoseAFG / S&P
-10.69% / 13.45%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.66% / 11.78%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
15.23 / 28.13
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.57 / 5.27
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.42m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.11b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
2025-Q20/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-3.30% / 10.94%
LoseAFG / S&P
3.04% / 4.83%
LoseAFG / S&P
-14.07% / 10.63%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.21% / 11.45%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.78 / 27.10
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.33 / 5.01
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.42m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.23b
2025-Q11/3 WinAFG / S&P
-1.95% / -4.27%
LoseAFG / S&P
3.52% / 4.98%
LoseAFG / S&P
-8.81% / 10.57%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.66% / 11.39%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.75 / 26.23
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.50 / 4.69
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.42m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.10b
2024-Q42/3 WinAFG / S&P
5.29% / 2.41%
WinAFG / S&P
6.35% / 5.25%
LoseAFG / S&P
5.28% / 6.15%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.66% / 11.29%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.96 / 28.60
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.57 / 4.99
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.28m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.08b
2024-Q32/3 WinAFG / S&P
10.03% / 5.89%
WinAFG / S&P
7.62% / 5.89%
LoseAFG / S&P
4.92% / 6.11%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.84% / 10.87%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.62 / 28.09
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.40 / 4.94
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.28m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.21b
2024-Q22/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-9.36% / 4.28%
WinAFG / S&P
7.47% / 5.38%
WinAFG / S&P
5.90% / 5.12%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.06% / 10.85%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.58 / 27.64
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.35 / 4.79
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.28m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.36b
2024-Q13/3 WinAFG / S&P
17.88% / 10.56%
WinAFG / S&P
11.14% / 5.71%
WinAFG / S&P
8.52% / 5.59%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.03% / 10.81%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.98 / 27.02
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.70 / 4.71
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.28m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.12b
2023-Q41/3 LoseAFG / S&P
8.66% / 11.69%
WinAFG / S&P
11.18% / 6.81%
LoseAFG / S&P
-4.65% / 7.78%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.89% / 11.19%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.67 / 24.35
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.34 / 4.31
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.01b
2023-Q31/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-5.45% / -3.27%
WinAFG / S&P
11.70% / 7.52%
LoseAFG / S&P
-11.50% / -5.03%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.27% / 10.84%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.86 / 23.93
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.36 / 3.98
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.24b
2023-Q21/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-1.76% / 8.74%
WinAFG / S&P
12.86% / 9.50%
LoseAFG / S&P
-17.42% / -8.57%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.38% / 10.88%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.81 / 24.01
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.52 / 4.19
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.17b
2023-Q10/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-8.46% / 7.50%
LoseAFG / S&P
8.46% / 10.77%
LoseAFG / S&P
-55.97% / -15.69%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.40% / 10.82%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.62 / 22.66
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.63 / 3.93
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $4.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.13b
2022-Q41/3 WinAFG / S&P
13.84% / 7.56%
LoseAFG / S&P
7.45% / 11.88%
LoseAFG / S&P
-54.79% / -17.99%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.76% / 11.09%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.03 / 22.65
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.89 / 3.75
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.70m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.15b
2022-Q30/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-11.08% / -4.88%
LoseAFG / S&P
5.56% / 13.47%
LoseAFG / S&P
-57.24% / -1.41%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
14.22% / 12.28%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.71 / 20.58
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.66 / 3.60
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.70m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.17b
2022-Q21/3 WinAFG / S&P
1.38% / -16.10%
LoseAFG / S&P
5.23% / 13.71%
LoseAFG / S&P
-53.69% / 11.04%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
15.53% / 13.03%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.46 / 20.28
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.91 / 3.78
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.70m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.17b
2022-Q11/3 WinAFG / S&P
8.07% / -4.60%
LoseAFG / S&P
6.56% / 15.97%
LoseAFG / S&P
33.07% / 42.23%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
28.14% / 14.22%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.64 / 22.19
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.56 / 4.51
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.70m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.20b
2021-Q42/3 WinAFG / S&P
14.38% / 11.03%
LoseAFG / S&P
13.57% / 15.00%
WinAFG / S&P
182.65% / 96.40%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
30.45% / 15.13%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
5.85 / 23.63
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.33 / 4.73
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.63m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.13b
2021-Q33/3 WinAFG / S&P
6.12% / 0.58%
WinAFG / S&P
56.34% / 10.77%
WinAFG / S&P
862.37% / 69.42%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
35.84% / 14.13%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
4.58 / 25.35
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
2.04 / 4.38
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.63m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.19b
2021-Q23/3 WinAFG / S&P
21.94% / 8.55%
WinAFG / S&P
33.41% / 6.58%
WinAFG / S&P
925.49% / 51.81%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
36.09% / 13.34%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
4.64 / 26.70
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.89 / 4.43
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.63m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.11b
2021-Q13/3 WinAFG / S&P
30.96% / 6.17%
WinAFG / S&P
18.67% / -1.06%
WinAFG / S&P
468.17% / 7.39%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
23.33% / 11.60%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.69 / 30.50
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.45 / 4.23
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.63m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.10b
2020-Q42/3 WinAFG / S&P
34.83% / 12.15%
LoseAFG / S&P
-7.15% / -3.72%
WinAFG / S&P
-16.43% / -33.42%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.69% / 8.86%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.34 / 39.26
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.11 / 4.05
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.17m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.01b
2020-Q30/3 LoseAFG / S&P
6.36% / 8.93%
LoseAFG / S&P
-46.62% / -2.04%
LoseAFG / S&P
-61.46% / -27.10%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.03% / 9.24%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
23.29 / 34.27
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
0.92 / 3.65
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.17m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.02b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
2020-Q20/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-8.92% / 20.54%
LoseAFG / S&P
-38.44% / -0.46%
LoseAFG / S&P
-67.64% / -27.11%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
4.95% / 9.37%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
24.04 / 31.29
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
0.92 / 3.44
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.17m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.03b
2020-Q10/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-35.82% / -19.60%
LoseAFG / S&P
-30.59% / 3.47%
LoseAFG / S&P
-63.32% / -14.75%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
5.09% / 10.68%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
23.58 / 22.80
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.25 / 2.92
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.17m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.05b
2019-Q41/3 LoseAFG / S&P
3.82% / 9.07%
LoseAFG / S&P
-13.10% / 5.36%
WinAFG / S&P
68.55% / 2.99%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
14.44% / 12.81%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.04 / 22.78
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.58 / 3.53
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.05b
2019-Q32/3 WinAFG / S&P
5.65% / 1.70%
WinAFG / S&P
7.28% / 5.02%
LoseAFG / S&P
-9.61% / 0.21%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
8.43% / 12.41%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
14.79 / 22.44
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.54 / 3.30
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.09b
2019-Q23/3 WinAFG / S&P
8.57% / 4.30%
WinAFG / S&P
8.27% / 6.64%
WinAFG / S&P
34.01% / 8.65%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.29% / 12.79%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.90 / 21.37
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.51 / 3.32
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.27b
2019-Q12/3 LoseAFG / S&P
6.73% / 13.65%
WinAFG / S&P
9.37% / 8.12%
WinAFG / S&P
52.12% / 14.29%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.45% / 12.97%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
12.08 / 20.86
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.52 / 3.26
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.08m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $34.35b
2018-Q40/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-16.88% / -13.52%
LoseAFG / S&P
4.15% / 9.05%
LoseAFG / S&P
10.38% / 18.23%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
7.41% / 13.10%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
15.25 / 19.39
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.63 / 2.94
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.00m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.01b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
2018-Q30/3 LoseAFG / S&P
3.72% / 7.71%
LoseAFG / S&P
6.98% / 10.21%
LoseAFG / S&P
2.56% / 19.06%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.98% / 13.01%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.65 / 22.25
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.92 / 3.45
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.00m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.17b
2018-Q20/3 LoseAFG / S&P
-2.75% / 3.43%
LoseAFG / S&P
6.47% / 9.03%
LoseAFG / S&P
-34.01% / 14.46%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
7.50% / 12.56%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
17.97 / 22.49
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.88 / 3.25
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.00m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.19b
2018-Q11/3 WinAFG / S&P
3.73% / -0.76%
LoseAFG / S&P
4.68% / 7.68%
LoseAFG / S&P
-34.60% / 12.46%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.76% / 12.27%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
21.36 / 23.41
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.92 / 3.17
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $3.00m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.08b
2017-Q41/3 WinAFG / S&P
7.29% / 6.64%
LoseAFG / S&P
5.65% / 7.03%
LoseAFG / S&P
-27.79% / 13.82%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.92% / 12.09%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
20.17 / 24.25
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.80 / 3.23
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.92m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.05b
2017-Q32/3 LoseAFG / S&P
4.43% / 4.48%
WinAFG / S&P
6.51% / 5.68%
WinAFG / S&P
75.90% / 17.57%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.21% / 12.04%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
13.13 / 23.28
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.69 / 3.08
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.92m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.11b
2017-Q22/3 WinAFG / S&P
6.11% / 3.09%
LoseAFG / S&P
4.76% / 4.83%
WinAFG / S&P
127.30% / 17.74%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.88% / 11.96%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.04 / 23.40
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.65 / 3.03
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.92m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.08b
2017-Q13/3 WinAFG / S&P
8.67% / 6.07%
WinAFG / S&P
4.37% / 3.67%
WinAFG / S&P
62.63% / 13.32%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
10.62% / 11.75%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.92 / 23.60
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.61 / 3.01
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.92m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $20.24b
2016-Q43/3 WinAFG / S&P
19.45% / 3.82%
WinAFG / S&P
5.74% / 2.09%
WinAFG / S&P
86.29% / 7.05%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
9.99% / 11.37%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
11.80 / 23.76
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.56 / 2.91
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.88m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $1.11b
2016-Q32/3 LoseAFG / S&P
1.84% / 3.85%
WinAFG / S&P
4.99% / 0.20%
WinAFG / S&P
13.85% / -3.15%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
6.16% / 10.82%
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
16.57 / 24.22
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
1.26 / 2.78
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $2.88m
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.00b
Non-scoringAFG / S&P
AFG unavailable / $0.16b

Dividend-reinvested, split-adjusted total return

1Y · 2025-08-29 to 2026-08-27

MetricAFG total returnS&P 500 Total Return Index
Total return10.56%20.78%
Annualized return10.56%20.78%

5Y · 2021-09-01 to 2026-08-27

MetricAFG total returnS&P 500 Total Return Index
Total return56.52%83.14%
Annualized return9.37%12.86%

10Y · 2016-09-01 to 2026-08-27

MetricAFG total returnS&P 500 Total Return Index
Total return299.93%319.30%
Annualized return14.87%15.41%

Calculation rules

window
Latest 40 completed benchmark quarters; unavailable issuer evidence remains visible and scores 0.
return Basis
Issuer adjusted close reinvests distributions and normalizes splits; the S&P 500 Total Return Index is the direct benchmark.
point Rule
Strict same-quarter win = 1. Loss, tie or unavailable evidence = 0. No partial or subjective points.
frequency
Quarter endpoints only.
fundamentals
Trailing-four-quarter issuer revenue and EPS growth use the issuer's normalized government-filed facts.
non Scoring
Net margin, P/E, P/B and other gray context columns never enter the score.

Snapshot captured 2026-09-04.